Ronan O'Gara has stepped into the most delicate conversation in Irish rugby, and the verdict from a 128-cap fly-half turned La Rochelle coach is clear. The battle to succeed Johnny Sexton is now a multi-year audition, and on Saturday night at the Stade de France, Sam Prendergast carries the jersey and the test.
Speaking pitchside to ITV Sport before Ireland's Six Nations clash with France, O'Gara did not pretend to be impartial. He grew up in Cork, watched Jack Crowley come through there, and admitted his own bias. "I'm a big fan of Jack Crowley. Of course I am," O'Gara said. "I like everything what he stands for. I like his competitiveness. I like his dog."
He also made it plain Crowley's demotion to the bench carried a sharper edge than a selection call. "I think he'll have a point to prove coming off the bench," O'Gara said. "I think maybe he thought that this jersey was his. It's only when you kind of get threatened, I think, you see another side to your character. So I think he'll be good tonight when he gets in."
O'Gara's technical verdict on Prendergast, however, was the moment that will travel. The Munster ten, who struggled against France in 2025, needed a game plan with a weapon, and O'Gara thinks he has one. "The big point of difference with Sam Prendergast is his right foot," O'Gara said. "He's got a beautiful right foot with drilled spirals. I think with the conditions tonight, it's undefendable if you hit them well, because what happens is that the ball accelerates off the surface, so it gains speed. So it'll be impossible for Ramos to get near the ball. So it could be an exhibition in 50/22s."
Then, almost aside, O'Gara offered a line that would have been legally useful if it had made it into the Irish dressing room. "If I could leak a bit of information into the dressing room, I think he should attempt them and attempt even 10 of them. And if four of them come off, Ireland have a good chance of winning the game."
Zoomed out, O'Gara framed the bigger problem. Ireland has not found a long-term Sexton successor because the standard they set during the Farrell era has raised the bar so high. "The standard has risen and it's got better," he said. "Johnny was so dominant in that position that Jack Crowley came in and everyone forgets how good he was in the first Six Nations season, which ended in a comprehensive victory in Marseilles. It looked like at that stage that he's going to have the jersey for 10 years, then enter Sam Prendergast, and there's obviously the Ciaran Frawley and there's Harry Byrne."
O'Gara believes the room for error has collapsed. "When I used to play rugby, I was able to make mistakes and stay in the Irish team. It's so ruthless nowadays. You just can't do that."
He also had a reality check for anyone writing off France at the Stade de France. "This place at 80,000 people is not a ground in the world like it," he said. "When they get momentum, they get confidence. I train these guys every day. I don't think I've seen a performance graph with the capacity to have such a variance. People having a bad day in Ireland might be 60 per cent, and if they're having a good day they could have 90. If you're French, it could be 20 and you could also get to 95. That's a huge difference."
Finally, O'Gara turned to his La Rochelle charge Ulupano Seuteni, who suffered a serious injury recently. "It feels like we've been in a daze for maybe six months," he said, "but the reality is that he's alive, he's kicking, he's in good health, and he's in good hands. He gave everyone a fright. He's just such a lovable guy that he means so much to everyone in La Rochelle."
For a pundit who lives one fly-half rivalry every week at La Rochelle, O'Gara's calm, technical, affectionate read on Ireland's 10s was also the most honest.
---
*Originally published on [Rugby News Online](https://rugbynews.online/article/an-exhibition-in-50-22s-ronan-o-gara-s-blueprint-for-sam-prendergast-in-fra-fb314a). Visit for full coverage.*
